Abstract
Background: Interorganisational collaboration is currently being promoted to improve the performance
of NHS providers. However, up to now, there has, to the best of our knowledge, been no systematic
attempt to assess the effect of different approaches to collaboration or to understand the mechanisms
through which interorganisational collaborations can work in particular contexts.
Objectives: Our objectives were to (1) explore the main strands of the literature about
interorganisational collaboration and to identify the main theoretical and conceptual frameworks, (2)
assess the empirical evidence with regard to how different interorganisational collaborations may (or
may not) lead to improved performance and outcomes, (3) understand and learn from NHS evidence
users and other stakeholders about how and where interorganisational collaborations can best be used
to support turnaround processes, (4) develop a typology of interorganisational collaboration that
considers different types and scales of collaboration appropriate to NHS provider contexts and (5)
generate evidence-informed practical guidance for NHS providers, policy-makers and others with
responsibility for implementing and assessing interorganisational collaboration arrangements.
Design: A realist synthesis was carried out to develop, test and refine theories about how
interorganisational collaborations work, for whom and in what circumstances.
Data sources: Data sources were gathered from peer-reviewed and grey literature, realist interviews
with 34 stakeholders and a focus group with patient and public representatives.
Review methods: Initial theories and ideas were gathered from scoping reviews that were gleaned and
refined through a realist review of the literature. A range of stakeholder interviews and a focus group
sought to further refine understandings of what works, for whom and in what circumstances with regard
to high-performing interorganisational collaborations.
Results: A realist review and synthesis identified key mechanisms, such as trust, faith, confidence and
risk tolerance, within the functioning of effective interorganisational collaborations. A stakeholder
analysis refined this understanding and, in addition, developed a new programme theory of collaborative
performance, with mechanisms related to cultural efficacy, organisational efficiency and technological