Abstract
Salmonella Enteritidis (SE) and, to a lesser extent, Salmonella Typhimurium (ST) are associated with egg related outbreaks in people. Recently, monophasic (lacking one phase of the flagellar antigen) strains of ST (mST) have been described, and they have officially been classified as variants of ST, and thus may contribute to human exposure to contaminated eggs. Currently used vaccination programmes are licensed for use against biphasic variants of ST, and their efficacy against mST has not yet been investigated. In this study, the effectiveness of four vaccination programmes currently in use in the UK poultry industry was evaluated against challenge with one SE strain, one ST strain and 2 monophasic ST strains. A Bayesian model was used to estimate the impact of vaccination on the rate of faecal shedding, and on egg contamination. For the majority of vaccine/challenge strain combinations, there was little or no effect of vaccination on the proportion of birds shedding Salmonella for either biphasic or monophasic strains. However, vaccination was effective at reducing egg contamination. A significantly lower proportion of eggshells were positive for the vaccinated birds compared to non-vaccinated birds, including the mST strains (vaccination resulted in a 55 and 21% reduction for the 2 mST strains). Calculated across all strains, the estimated rate of positive egg contents was lower in vaccinated birds (Bayesian median was 0.13% for vaccinated versus 0.27% for non-vaccinated birds). For both vaccinated and unvaccinated birds, there was also an apparent difference in the proportion of organs positive between strains, with the SE strain resulting in a lower proportion of positive organs at post-mortem examination compared to the other strains.